US District Judge Jessica Clarke has issued an acquittal for two brothers who faced accusations of taking $25 million in cryptocurrency within approximately 12 seconds by leveraging a flaw in the Ethereum blockchain. The ruling follows a mistrial declared one year earlier when jurors could not reach consensus on whether to convict or acquit the defendants, former MIT students Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, marking what prosecutors described as an unprecedented case of its kind.

In her decision, Judge Clarke stated: "The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes. It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the Government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case." She continued: "Because the Government failed to prove that the Peraire-Buenos made any material misrepresentations in the execution of their scheme, the motion is granted, and a judgment of acquittal is entered for Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno."

image

The brothers were detained in Boston and New York in May 2024 on charges of wire fraud and money laundering, with each count carrying a potential 20-year prison sentence upon conviction.

The prosecution's allegations

According to the government's case, the defendants allegedly interfered with blockchain transaction validation by gaining access to unconfirmed private transactions, modifying them, extracting cryptocurrency from victims, and refusing to restore the taken funds.

Prosecutors contended that the brothers studied their targets' trading patterns beginning in December 2022 before executing the attack and took steps to conceal both the stolen assets and their own identities. The indictment alleged they maintained multiple cryptocurrency addresses, utilized foreign exchanges, and established shell companies to obscure the flow of funds.

The government's account described a multi-stage operation involving several key components:

  • Deployment of "bait transactions" intended to identify potential victims among active traders
  • Exploitation of a vulnerability in the MEV-Boost relay code that caused premature disclosure of a proposed block's full contents
  • Reordering of the proposed block to benefit the attackers
  • Reordering of the block on the Ethereum blockchain itself, resulting in the approximately $25 million theft from victim traders

Prosecutors also alleged that during the planning and execution phases, the brothers conducted online searches about executing the attack, concealing their participation in the Ethereum exploit, and moving criminal proceeds through cryptocurrency exchanges with minimal identity verification requirements. The government further claimed they retained legal counsel specializing in cryptocurrency matters, extradition law, and the specific crimes outlined in the indictment.